Brand Identity
March 22, 2024

How to Reposition Your Small Business Brand for a New Audience

Your brand is built for a specific audience at a specific moment in your business. When that audience shifts — when you grow upmarket, enter a new geography, or evolve

Consort Creative
Repositioning Your Brand for a New Target Audience

Your brand is built for a specific audience at a specific moment in your business. When that audience shifts — when you grow upmarket, enter a new geography, or evolve your service offering — your brand needs to shift with it. Repositioning isn’t about abandoning what you’ve built. It’s about making sure what you present to the world still reflects who you serve.

What Makes Your Brand Special?

New Fans, New Message:

If your business has grown or your customers have changed, then your brand message might need an update too. Find out who your new audience is and what they like. Do some research to understand their needs, and then tailor your message to connect better.

Standing Out in the Crowd:

If your brand looks just like everyone else’s, then it’s time to change it up. Start by checking your messaging, personality, and overall look to see how you can be more unique. Ask yourself, what makes your brand special? Consider the things you care about and what your customers might like. For example, are you kind to the environment? Do you help your community? By highlighting these things, you can better connect with your audience.

Missing the Mark:

Once you know your audience and competitors better, see how you’re presenting yourself. Is your message the same across all your marketing and advertising? Do your website, social media, and other stuff all look and feel similar? A clear and consistent brand is easier to remember. If your message is clear but people aren’t interested, you might need to rethink your entire brand message. You might also need a new logo, pictures, and personality to better reflect your new message.

Engagement is Down:

The way you talk to your audience can also affect your brand. If you see fewer people visiting your website, liking your social media posts, or opening your emails, it might be a sign to revisit your brand message. Use information you collect online to see what works and what doesn’t. Are people staying on your website for a long time or leaving quickly? To grab attention, you need to create content that’s interesting and relevant.

Big Business Changes:

If your business offerings have changed a lot, your brand message might need an update too. A company that used to sell toys but now offers online games would need to reflect this shift in its message.

Repositioning Your Brand for a New Target Audience -  Brand Reposition, A Brand building graph on top of a desk.

Keeping Your Brand Strong

Repositioning your brand is like taking care of a garden. You need to check on it regularly and make changes as needed. If your brand isn’t connecting with customers, isn’t standing out, or is targeting the wrong audience, consider repositioning. By understanding your audience, competitors, and refining your message and identity, you can effectively reposition your brand for success.

  • During target audience analysis: Explore not just who your audience is, but also what kind of brand association you want to create with them. For instance, are you aiming for a brand perceived as reliable, innovative, or luxurious?
  • Competitive analysis: Don’t just identify what competitors do, but also  what image they’ve built. Understanding their positioning helps you choose a distinct space in the market.
  • Messaging and brand identity: Crafting messaging and visuals shouldn’t just be about clarity, but about  conveying the desired brand perception. For example, a brand aiming for a playful image might use a quirky logo and lighthearted language.

What Brand Repositioning Actually Involves

Brand repositioning for a small business is more substantive than a logo update — but it doesn’t necessarily require a full rebrand. The core of repositioning is strategic: redefining who your ideal client is, how you describe what you do and why it matters to them, and what visual and verbal identity best represents that updated position.

A typical small business repositioning project covers: an audience reanalysis (who are you actually best suited to serve now?), a competitive landscape review (what positioning is already occupied in your market?), a messaging update (how does your value proposition need to be reframed for the new audience?), and a visual identity assessment (does your current brand communicate the right qualities to the new target?). Depending on the answers, this may result in messaging changes only, a visual refresh, or a more comprehensive identity update.

The timeline for a repositioning project is typically 4–6 weeks — similar to a brand refresh. The investment is similar as well: strategy and messaging updates tend to be less expensive than full visual redesign, so if the visual identity is sound for the new audience, the project can focus on strategy and copy rather than design.

A Small Business Repositioning Example

A marketing consultant who built their practice serving startup founders decides, after five years, that their best clients are established professional services firms — law offices, accounting practices, financial advisors — looking to modernize their client acquisition. Their service offering hasn’t changed. Their skills are directly applicable. But their brand — built for startup culture, using language like ‘disrupt’, ‘iterate’, and ‘growth hacking’ — actively repels the conservative professional services audience they now want to attract.

Repositioning in this case doesn’t require a new name or a full redesign. It requires: updated positioning language (‘helping established professional firms attract and retain the right clients’), messaging that speaks to the concerns of law partners and accounting principals rather than startup founders, a visual identity that signals credibility and experience rather than agility and speed, and a portfolio that foregrounds the relevant work rather than the startup projects.

After repositioning, the consultant’s website, LinkedIn, and materials speak directly to the new audience. The old startup clients who find the new site still engage if they’re a fit — the repositioned message is more specific, not exclusionary. But the right clients — the ones who were previously repelled by startup language — now see themselves in the brand immediately.

FAQ: Brand Repositioning for Small Businesses

How do I know if my small business brand needs repositioning?

How long does brand repositioning take for a small business?

What’s the difference between brand repositioning and rebranding?

Can I reposition my brand without changing my logo?

How much does brand repositioning cost?

Tired of Blah B2B Branding? We Can Help.

Consort Creative is a top branding, positioning, and black owned design firm. We help companies build brands that connect with customers on an emotional level and boost sales.

What makes us different?

  • Industry Smarts: Our team knows the ins and outs of B2B and B2C.
  • Data Drives Decisions: We use a special research system to make sure your brand plan is based on real facts.
  • Focus on Your Growth: You concentrate on running your business, and we’ll handle building your brand and getting you more leads.

Ready for a Brand that Shines?

Let’s chat! Schedule a consultation today or contact us.

- READY TO ACT ON THIS

Your Brand Should Be Working While You're Not.

If this article resonated, the next step is a free 30-minute conversation. No pitch, no pressure — just clarity about where your brand stands and what's worth fixing first.